Get Out. It was the movie that did and will stick with me. It had the most interesting and surprising premise. It was multidimensional--funny, scary, moving, meaningful. Number two is hard as Dunkirk was an amazing movie--very creative in its own way, very much the epic of the year. But Shape of Water was also very multidimensional--Cold War spy thriller, sci-fi fish out of water (sorry), and romance. Oh, and fish sex. I saw Dunkirk a while ago so it is hard to compare with Shape of Water. I did pay heaps of attention to the direction and editing of both, probably because of my daughter, Intern Spew, and her nascent film career. Three Billboards was quite good and moving, but the racist redemption thing kind of took me out of the movie a bit. Lady Bird? Incredibly well acted but not all that special to me. Sorry.
No vote for Best Actor as I saw only one of those--Daniel Kaluuya in Get Out.
Frances McDormand was just a force. Sally Hawkins comes close because she was so very good, so very expressive despite not being able to talk. Saoirse Ronan was very good, but the role was not that special.
Best Supporting Actor:
Despite the whole problematic redemptive racist thing, Rockwell pulled it off really well. Jenkins was very good in Shape, but didn't help to make the movie. Harrelson was fine in a small role--moving, but replaceable.
Best Supporting Actress:
Metcalf in a runaway. Ok, I only saw two of the nominees, and Olivia Spencer was very good but again the movie didn't hang at all on her. Metcalf helped to make Lady Bird be a notable flick.
Best movie should get best director, but I am inclined to give the writing award to Jordan Peele and the directing to either Nolan or del Toro since their movies were harder, more epic. Hmmm. Good thing I don't have a vote.
Best Original Screenplay:
Get Out. It had better writing and a more interesting plot than the others--I saw all five of the nominees.
Logan.... only one I saw.