Tried to find good pun for title and failed miserably. Anyway, I was struck by an experience I had yesterday. I interviewed a member of the Denmark's Liberal Party (Venstre is its name in Danish), and was surprised to find a bunch of bumper-stickers/posters that were Bush/Cheney and McCain/Palin (talk about dodging a bullet....).
And I realized that Liberal in the Danish context refers to the traditional Liberal definition of free trade, property rights, and so forth. So distinct from the American political context where Liberals are on the left end of the spectrum, seeking government intervention to compensate for the problems induced by market capitalism (unemployment, poverty, etc.).
And distinct from Liberal theory in IR, which focuses more or less on how the pattern of interests domestically and internationally drive events (rather than the distribution of power [realism] or the content of identities [constructivism]). I find myself more in the Liberal category of IR theory than in any other (although my students think I am a hard-core realist).
But this got me thinking about how elastic (and perhaps even intersubjective) such labels are. After all, the least conservative people these days in the American political system are folks who call themselves Conservatives. They (well, many of them) are not trying to preserve a way of life or an existing political order, but trying to destroy existing institutions and patterns of behavior (theocracy, anyone?). "Conservative" judges are as or more guilty of judicial activism and the denial of states' rights as liberal ones.
So, are these labels meaningless? No, identities do matter, but we need to take care to figure out their content--which changes over time in response to events, political entrepreneurs, and so forth.
Yes, I am practicing to get back into lecture mode, having not taught for more than eight months.
International Relations, Ethnic Conflict, Civil-Military Relations, Academia, Politics in General, Selected Silliness
Wednesday, August 25, 2010
Copenhagen, Day 5
While I am changing from my suit to jeans after having a very interesting discussion with three Ministry of Defense people and one Army officer, I thought I would post a few more things I have observed in Copenhagne:
- Of all the cities I have traveled through the past year (Berlin, London, Paris, Canberra, Sydney, Wellington and now Copenhagen), Copenhagen has far more police/ambulance sirens going off. Perhaps I am in a lousy neighborhood? More graffiti than most of these other places as well, I think. But still does not feel like a dangerous place.
- A correction: the wind is stronger here than in Lubbock, more like Wellington. Nor is the wind here particularly chewy.
- Another correction: weekday Copenhagen Danes are much more fit than weekenders. Biking is apparently really good for the environment.
- And I prefer Carsberg Classic which is darker than the regular Carlsberg.
More Evidence that DADT Is Undermining US Military
This story about gays and lesbians at the US Military Academy just serves as more evidence that we need to hustle a bit faster to get rid of this obsolete restriction.
I'd love to see if a reporter could find a similar group of folks willing to talk to a journalist at the US Air Force Academy, given its status as an outpost of evangelical proselytizing. Distrust must be incredibly high there.
“Anyone you meet here,” the senior female cadet said, “you have to assess their personality very closely, and see if you can trust them.”This is not only sad but destructive. Creating an environment of fear and distrust among the future officers in the military is awful. How will these officers work together down the road?
I'd love to see if a reporter could find a similar group of folks willing to talk to a journalist at the US Air Force Academy, given its status as an outpost of evangelical proselytizing. Distrust must be incredibly high there.
Tuesday, August 24, 2010
Arctic Sovereignty From Another Point of View
Even with the recent news that Canadian politicians have discovered reason, it has been fun to occasionally talk about Arctic Sovereignty with the Danes, given that Canadian folks have portrayed them as card-carrying members of the Axis of Icy Imperialism© along with Russia and the US. So, one member of parliament chatted with me about the required visits of one of Denmark's few ships to Greenland and the contested area (Hans Island) and the deployment of Danish forces to take down the Canadian flag and replace it with a Danish one.
The Dane put it in terms of Canadian aggression. Holy oxymoron, Batman!
The Dane put it in terms of Canadian aggression. Holy oxymoron, Batman!
Copenhagen, Day 4
What happened to day 3? Interviews and then rain so I didn't have much in the way of observations. Except one: you always know you are getting close to the US embassy in a country as the bike path/road/sidewalk suddenly become blocked with ugly concrete planters. Today, while walking to the Royal Danish Defence College, I was wondering around the neighboring suburb to waste some time (I got there early), and thought I was running into another US facility. Nope, close though, as the Israeli Embassy (or residence) was surrounded by various obstacles to make approaching by vehicle quite hard.
Anyhow, what did I learn during my fourth day in Copenhagen:
Anyhow, what did I learn during my fourth day in Copenhagen:
- It is just like Lubbock. It is incredibly flat and incredibly windy at time. But otherwise not so much unless you can imagine the bikes here to be the equivalent of Chevy Suburbans.
- It is just like the Island on Lost, as it spontaneously rains even when it is sunny and then stops immediately, almost as if John Locke was anticipating it all.
- Last year, I noted that Paris, Berlin and London vary in how much they trust their citizens to pay for the metro/train. Paris--very untrusting--with very difficult obstacles to surmount if you don't pay. Berlin--complete trust with the possibility of an inspection. Copenhagen--same as Berlin.
- Train was also funky in that an entire car (or more) was dedicated to bikers and their bikes, with stands built in. The trains also have "quiet" zones and anti-quiet zones (wifi). Interestingly, you will find less English in the metro/train system in Copenhagen than in the cities I experienced last year. They make up for it by using English in the names and advertisements of their shoppes. The pic here is for boots and shoes, which are semi-underwater here.
- Truthers are even here. Ug. Right outside the Parliament.
Americans and Canadians Can See Eye to Eye On One Thing, at least
Paying for ketchup at a burger joint for one's fries is just wrong.
The Future of Peer Review
Shall we wiki peer review? This article presents one model of replacing peer review with online review. I don't know. I guess I am not as frustrated as some with peer review, as I have had some success, so I am not sure how broken it is. I do think some journals are far better at it than other--getting good reviewers to respond in a timely fashion. By good reviewers, I mean folks who evaluate the article fairly for what it tries to be. Other journals are slower.
Who will be more fair and honest--a reviewer known only to the editor or folks on the web with their names attached? Anonymity on the web is not the best path to happiness as we have seen on many threads out there, and anonymity poses a similar risk via conventional reviewing except there are editors in the latter case.
But change is hard.
I will have to think more about this, but right now, I am not sure how broken the current system is, as most of the journals I review for and get reviewed by are pretty fast these days in terms of the review process. In terms of going from that stage to publishing, things are much slower, but that is not about the review process.
Who will be more fair and honest--a reviewer known only to the editor or folks on the web with their names attached? Anonymity on the web is not the best path to happiness as we have seen on many threads out there, and anonymity poses a similar risk via conventional reviewing except there are editors in the latter case.
But change is hard.
The most daunting obstacle to opening up the process is that peer-review publishing is the path to a job and tenure, and no would-be professor wants to be the academic canary in the coal mine.Indeed.
I will have to think more about this, but right now, I am not sure how broken the current system is, as most of the journals I review for and get reviewed by are pretty fast these days in terms of the review process. In terms of going from that stage to publishing, things are much slower, but that is not about the review process.
Monday, August 23, 2010
In Loco Parentis/Loco Parents
Last year, when I enumerated the ups and downs of prof-ing, I forgot to mention one of the best parents: No Parents. Apparently, this generation of parents needs to be reminded to go home. I have only had a few interactions with parents in my 17 years or so of prof-ing. The few times have mostly been prospective students wandering around with their parents, pondering their future. I have not had to deal with parents when dealing with plagiarism cases or bad grades .... yet.
I think the NYT story linked above is probably exaggerating things a bit, but the students at McGill are probably a little less entitled and probably have had a great deal more independence than American students in general (holy generalizations, Batman). But when my friends and I complain while eating/drinking/playing poker at the various conferences, parents are never the subject of complaints.
I have always thought of this as one of the huge differences between prof-ing and teaching K-12.
I think the NYT story linked above is probably exaggerating things a bit, but the students at McGill are probably a little less entitled and probably have had a great deal more independence than American students in general (holy generalizations, Batman). But when my friends and I complain while eating/drinking/playing poker at the various conferences, parents are never the subject of complaints.
I have always thought of this as one of the huge differences between prof-ing and teaching K-12.
With Friends Like These
People wonder why there has not been as much of an outpouring of support for the people of Pakistan. Well, perhaps it is because many folks are not fans of their government. True, the people suffering from the floods have little control over their government, but when their government crows over upsetting a peace process because they were excluded, it tends to alienate the planet.
Is it fair or right that this diminishes support for the people struck by this horrible tragedy? Certainly not. But Pakistan as a government raises big questions about the limits of power and of patience.
“We picked up Baradar and the others because they were trying to make a deal without us,” said a Pakistani security official, who, like numerous people interviewed about the operation, spoke anonymously because of the delicacy of relations between Pakistan, Afghanistan and the United States. “We protect the Taliban. They are dependent on us. We are not going to allow them to make a deal with Karzai and the Indians.”Sure, this latest news may not have affected attitudes, but those attitudes were already fairly set against Pakistan for the years of the double-game, getting lots of assistance while still providing refuge and support for the Taliban, for Al Qaeda, and for terrorist groups aimed at India.
Is it fair or right that this diminishes support for the people struck by this horrible tragedy? Certainly not. But Pakistan as a government raises big questions about the limits of power and of patience.
Sunday, August 22, 2010
The Jones and Product Placement
On the flight to Copenhagen, I ended up choosing to watch The Jones because its premise seemed interesting: four people (David Duchovny, Demi Moore, Amber Heard, and Ben Hollingswoth) pretend to be a family in order to promote a variety of products to a community of wealthy folks who are lemmings. This "family" is employed by a corporation (led by Lauren Hutton) that does this in a bunch of places to get folks to imitate and adopt new products. So, it is not a con but advertising....
This could have been a pretty clever satire about the commodification of self-value and so forth. But for 3/4's of the movie, the folks are shilling a mix of real and fake products (the cheap food stuffs are fake, I think), and the real stuff is probably the result of product placement. So, on the one hand, this makes the movie a bit more realistic with real stuff, but, on the other hand, the movie is selling products that most people cannot afford (indeed, Gary Cole's character bankrupts himself keeping up with the Jones). Kind of undercuts the message, methinks.
Mad Men does deal with real stuff (and I am not thrilled about having to wait a week to see the episode that plays tonight--have to watch the Will Ferrell basketball comedy instead!), but not in ways that undermine what they are trying to do, but exactly in ways that emphasize the themes.
This could have been a pretty clever satire about the commodification of self-value and so forth. But for 3/4's of the movie, the folks are shilling a mix of real and fake products (the cheap food stuffs are fake, I think), and the real stuff is probably the result of product placement. So, on the one hand, this makes the movie a bit more realistic with real stuff, but, on the other hand, the movie is selling products that most people cannot afford (indeed, Gary Cole's character bankrupts himself keeping up with the Jones). Kind of undercuts the message, methinks.
Mad Men does deal with real stuff (and I am not thrilled about having to wait a week to see the episode that plays tonight--have to watch the Will Ferrell basketball comedy instead!), but not in ways that undermine what they are trying to do, but exactly in ways that emphasize the themes.
Copenhagen, Day 2
Spent my second day and my last full day of tourism with a bit of history. First, I walked around and in Rosenborg Slot and Kongens Have. This is where the Royal types used to hang out. The castle was pretty interesting as were the gardens. Plus another nice moat These Danes know their moats. If I have get a Spew Mansion, I will hire Danes to do the moat.
Then I went to the Carlsberg Brewery. They had a nice visitor's area/museum dedicated to beer and the company. Very interesting stuff. And you get two beers at the end of the tour. Excellent.
Taking a break now to let my feet dry, and then more of the city.
One bit of frustration--my cell apparently is locked so new SIM card does not work. Other than that and the wet clothes, things are alright here in southern Scandinavia.
Part 2 abridged due to rain. Will have some other time this week to see stuff, but now time to prep for interviews.
Then I went to the Carlsberg Brewery. They had a nice visitor's area/museum dedicated to beer and the company. Very interesting stuff. And you get two beers at the end of the tour. Excellent.
Taking a break now to let my feet dry, and then more of the city.
One bit of frustration--my cell apparently is locked so new SIM card does not work. Other than that and the wet clothes, things are alright here in southern Scandinavia.
Part 2 abridged due to rain. Will have some other time this week to see stuff, but now time to prep for interviews.
Implications of Mosque Madness
Frank Rich does an excellent job of:
- developing the implications of the domestic demagoguery for the war in Afghanistan;
- reminding us of the hypocrisy that is FOX news
- informing me of something I had missed--the role of Saudis in funding FOX.
Saturday, August 21, 2010
Copenhagen, Day 1
Aside from getting in three hours or so late thanks to a broken plane in Newark (only a fuel leak!?), things went well today.
Of course, I realized quickly that I probably should not really talk about my research to the taxi driver if he is from Pakistan. Led to a 15 minute conversation about 9/11. Ug. But he was nice enough.
What have I learned about Copenhagen thus far and the Danes?
Of course, I realized quickly that I probably should not really talk about my research to the taxi driver if he is from Pakistan. Led to a 15 minute conversation about 9/11. Ug. But he was nice enough.
What have I learned about Copenhagen thus far and the Danes?
- The city is like Shrek and onions--it has many layers. The current building holding the parliament sits on top of pretty much every previous construction on that site since the 1100's! Really. So, one of the tourist sites are the "ruins" underneath the government center (Christianborg), which contains walls and bricks and wells from the previous forts/castles/etc. It turns out that one of the groups acting the early Danes was the Hanseatic League. Thanks to Hendrik Spruyt, I knew who these guys were. On the other hand, the Danes kept burning their own palaces down through bad design.
- An interesting contrast with Australia. In Syndey, it was hard to walk around the harborfront without bumping into seven weddings. Thus far, I have seen more weddings and wedding pictures near the Kastellet (former fortress, still rocks the widest moat I have ever seen). What can be over-read into this? That the viking blood of the past means that they associate marriage with defense and conquest? Surely not. Just a pretty area of the city, but Copenhagen has plenty of those.
- The Danes are not as uniformly blond as one might expect, but still pretty darn blond. They are not nearly as fit as residents of Oslo, although they seem to be less obese than North Americans (not that difficult a trick). What was surprising to me, given all of their hoopla about Muslims, is how few I have seen thus far, compared to how many head-scarved women I see in Montreal.
- The 7/11's are the busiest stores, which was a problem for me since they might have sim cards so that I can use my Canadian phone with a Danish number and less $$$. But that might just have been because of the huge crowd that showed up for some sort of gay rights/pride event. It was good to see Batman and Robin show up, but it led me to wonder which version of B&R was more homoerotic--the original TV show or the George Clooney/Chris O'Donnell version?
- I do wonder about the competitiveness of Danish Dairy as both Ben and Jerry's and Cold Stone Creamery have outlets here.
- The Wire has absolutely re-wired my brain. I am in towards the end of the second season (which rocks, despite some thinking it is one of the weaker ones--all I have to say is Omar in court) and now when I see a port, I think about cans being diverted.
- Oh, and I just noticed that my very basic hotel room has a bottle opener attached to the desk in the most obvious way possible--more than any other hotel room I can remember. Hmmmmm.
Mo (sque) Hypocrisy
This really requires no comment:
So just to make it clear, the GOP has now staked a claim as the defenders of the sanctity of the Ground Zero site, but they have simultaneously VOTED to deny the necessary long-term healthcare and compensation for the rescue workers and first responders who struggled in the ruins of Ground Zero.
I was having trouble thinking of a word to describe people like this, and then I remembered.....HYPOCRITES.
Friday, August 20, 2010
When A Break In Policy Is A Return to Tradition: Canada and the Arctic
The Harper govt has decided to focus more on building rules to govern the arctic than confrontation with the menacing Danes, Americans and Russians. The article here pitches this as a break in policy. It might be a break with the past few years, but Canada has always realized that it does not have the leverage, the power to get bigger, more powerful countries to bend to its will. Instead, it has always sought to develop multilateral institutions (UN, NATO, NAFTA) to tie down the giant to the south and realize Canadian interests through bargaining, rules and shared values. So, this move is hardly as revolutionary for Canada as it appears to be, although it may be a change in the Harper approach. But it was inevitable. And not unwise.
What Progress Looks Like
“When I go to downtown Baghdad, and I’m stuck in traffic, and I’m not jumping curbs, and going against traffic, I’m driving in traffic like everyone else — and I’m looking to my left and right, and there’s a guy selling fish,” he said at Forward Operating Base Falcon, a base on Baghdad’s outskirts.NYT has a good story about the experiences of the American soldiers in Iraq who are now on their way out.
“He’s got a fish cart. He’s cooking fish. And there’s a watermelon stand and then there’s an electronic store right next to it, and people are everywhere. And I’m sitting in traffic and I’m going, ‘Man, this is unbelievable.’ That’s a victory parade for me.”
Is Iraq fixed? Certainly not. The future is most uncertain, as it depends on Iraq's politics, Iran's interference, and a host of challenges. Is it better off now than before the Awakening and before the Surge? Absolutely. Was the invasion worth the cost? Um, no. Not at all, as too many Americans and too many Iraqis (and Italians and Brits and others) have paid with their lives for a foreign policy effort based on either lies or misperceptions or both (certainly an effort based on arrogance). Could we have lived with Saddam Hussein? Sure, we had done so for quite a while. Would the Iraqis have been better off with more years of autocracy or with the war and its costs? Hard to say, but the aggregate costs for the US in terms of lost opportunities in Afghanistan, a nearly broken military, deep budgetary holes, diplomatic costs that are still being felt, and so on, make the effort a net negative. We may have won the counter-insurgency campaign (for the time-being), but the war cost more than it got us.
But things are better now than they were a few years ago, so sticking it out for a bit longer was worth it. Whether it is sustainable, I don't know.
Welfare Rant #1
A friend of mine on facebook "liked" one of the groups or threads or whatever that tied together welfare and drug-users, basically complaining that our tax dollars are subsidizing drug abusers. And that pushed a button--my rant button.
I am no expert on welfare, but I did have to teach about it for several years at Texas Tech, so I did try to find some stuff out along the way. I may not be entirely accurate here, but as I understood it then (and I doubt it has changed much), the single most common event leading someone into poverty and onto welfare is .... divorce. Becoming a single mom is the event most associated with needing some sort of welfare program. One of my relatives got a divorce from an exemplar of a deadbeat dad, and she needed help from her state to get by. Food stamps made a difference until she was no longer eligible (I have to say that limit of eligibility was mighty, mighty low) once her deadbeat ex was required to pay child support of around $165 a month. The good news about this low assessment* is that it was small enough not to be missed that much when he didn't pay. Anyhow, so she got food stamps for a while, she got free counseling for her kids, her kids still are on Medicaid, and she has gotten subsidized day care and day camp so that she can continue to work.
Now that she has an hourly job, she is making too much money to get as much assistance from the state. What she could really use would be housing subsidies, but that does not seem to exist, I guess, in her state. She, of course, is also getting assistance from her family (her mother, us), and her deadbeat husband occasionally kicks in the $165 or so that he owes her but not regularly, not monthly. And so far, he has gotten away with that. We may have had a cultural shift in attitudes about deadbeat dads, but the actual enforcement is blunted when counties facing budget problems want to keep their prisons clear of folks who merely default on their financial obligations to their families.
Good times. So, pardon me if I do not really care if some tax dollars make it into the hands of folks who use drugs. I care more that some of this money actually does make it into the hands of single moms (and single dads, too) that have incredible responsibilities, difficult choices, and few options.
* The lesson is not to marry someone who owns their business because they can easily hide/deny their income.
I am no expert on welfare, but I did have to teach about it for several years at Texas Tech, so I did try to find some stuff out along the way. I may not be entirely accurate here, but as I understood it then (and I doubt it has changed much), the single most common event leading someone into poverty and onto welfare is .... divorce. Becoming a single mom is the event most associated with needing some sort of welfare program. One of my relatives got a divorce from an exemplar of a deadbeat dad, and she needed help from her state to get by. Food stamps made a difference until she was no longer eligible (I have to say that limit of eligibility was mighty, mighty low) once her deadbeat ex was required to pay child support of around $165 a month. The good news about this low assessment* is that it was small enough not to be missed that much when he didn't pay. Anyhow, so she got food stamps for a while, she got free counseling for her kids, her kids still are on Medicaid, and she has gotten subsidized day care and day camp so that she can continue to work.
Now that she has an hourly job, she is making too much money to get as much assistance from the state. What she could really use would be housing subsidies, but that does not seem to exist, I guess, in her state. She, of course, is also getting assistance from her family (her mother, us), and her deadbeat husband occasionally kicks in the $165 or so that he owes her but not regularly, not monthly. And so far, he has gotten away with that. We may have had a cultural shift in attitudes about deadbeat dads, but the actual enforcement is blunted when counties facing budget problems want to keep their prisons clear of folks who merely default on their financial obligations to their families.
Good times. So, pardon me if I do not really care if some tax dollars make it into the hands of folks who use drugs. I care more that some of this money actually does make it into the hands of single moms (and single dads, too) that have incredible responsibilities, difficult choices, and few options.
* The lesson is not to marry someone who owns their business because they can easily hide/deny their income.
Expertise--A Matter of Limits?
Dan Drezner has a great take on how one becomes an expert. I'd just like to point out that number 9 on the list is that an expert needs to recognize his/her limits. Indeed, knowing your limitations is an on-going theme here at the Spew. The more you know, the more you should be aware of what you do not know.
My year in the Pentagon was, as they say there, like drinking from the firehose--I got exposed to alot of information over a short period of time. So, I learned a great deal about how US foreign policy made. But I also realized that there is far more I do not really understand. I thought I knew how NATO worked, but I had no clue. The current project that takes me to Copenhagen this evening is aimed at answering some of the questions that were raised nearly ten years ago in the five-sided building.
Last night, I had a much better ultimate experience than the week before, in part because I didn't try to be the hero on the last possession, but instead made an easier pass to someone who then made the scoring pass into the endzone. Knowing my limits and those of my teammates has been, I think, one of my advantages on the field. I just have to adjust as my limits increase as I age.
My year in the Pentagon was, as they say there, like drinking from the firehose--I got exposed to alot of information over a short period of time. So, I learned a great deal about how US foreign policy made. But I also realized that there is far more I do not really understand. I thought I knew how NATO worked, but I had no clue. The current project that takes me to Copenhagen this evening is aimed at answering some of the questions that were raised nearly ten years ago in the five-sided building.
Last night, I had a much better ultimate experience than the week before, in part because I didn't try to be the hero on the last possession, but instead made an easier pass to someone who then made the scoring pass into the endzone. Knowing my limits and those of my teammates has been, I think, one of my advantages on the field. I just have to adjust as my limits increase as I age.
Thursday, August 19, 2010
Learning How to Read a Survey
Heaps of folks are tweeting/facebooking about the new survey that has 18% of Americans thinking Obama is a Muslims. First, as Drezner tweeted, you can get 20% of Americans to say pretty much anything (normal curves have thin tails--but the tails do exist). Second, this result is entirely driven by White evangelicals/conservative Republicans. The really consistent change is that more people don't know than before. So, Fox News has been successful in confusing people. Or perhaps Obama's tolerance is confusing--that if you tolerate a non-Christian religion, that makes people unsure of what you really are.... I wonder if Howard Dean's numbers or Bloomberg's numbers on this question would have the same pattern?
You know what? I would actually prefer that the American people didn't know what the religion of the President is. The President's standing should be on what they are doing, what they have done, what they promise to do, not where they worship or not. And, indeed, in the other questions, the majority of Americans feel that Obama is behaving correctly:
You know what? I would actually prefer that the American people didn't know what the religion of the President is. The President's standing should be on what they are doing, what they have done, what they promise to do, not where they worship or not. And, indeed, in the other questions, the majority of Americans feel that Obama is behaving correctly:
- Mentions faith/prayer about right (only white evangelicals/Republicans disagree);
- Relies on religious beliefs to make policy decisions about right, driven down mostly by white evangelicals who want religious beliefs to matter more. Um, thank you, but no thanks.
When Optics Require Innovation
The Status of Forces Agreement means that the US military has to be out of Iraq entirely by the end of 2011 with the combat brigades leaving this month. But the US still has aspirations of doing important stuff after 2011, so State leads and is guarded by ... contractors. Private military companies. I am sure that if you asked Iraqis which they would prefer, they would prefer to have US military guys doing this kind of work rather than contractors because the former are accountable and the latter not so much. But both Iraqi nationalism and American domestic politics require no American soldiers or Marines of any size to be in the country.
Yep, the policy is drive by optics--the uniforms would look bad on Iraqi and American TV. So, we must innovate and have a really large civilian presence guarded by contractors. But is this really a good idea? Probably not, but politics, as they say (this is a morning for cliches), is the art of the possible.
The former head civilian, Ryan Crocker, suggests that this should be revisited:
Blackwater Xe? Put that way, I am pretty sure that Iraqis would punish their politicians less for letting some troops stay. Framed as US troops or nothing is something else entirely. But first we need a settled Iraqi domestic political scene, which does not seem to be close at hand.
Yep, the policy is drive by optics--the uniforms would look bad on Iraqi and American TV. So, we must innovate and have a really large civilian presence guarded by contractors. But is this really a good idea? Probably not, but politics, as they say (this is a morning for cliches), is the art of the possible.
The former head civilian, Ryan Crocker, suggests that this should be revisited:
“We need strategic patience here,” Ryan C. Crocker, who served as ambassador in Iraq from 2007 until early 2009, said in an interview. “Our timetables are getting out ahead of Iraqi reality. We do have an Iraqi partner in this. We certainly are not the ones making unilateral decisions anymore. But if they come to us later on this year requesting that we jointly relook at the post-2011 period, it is going to be in our strategic interest to be responsive.”I think Obama could imagine keeping some troops around, so this really hinges on Iraqi politicians taking a brave stand. Perhaps they could frame a request for some US troops to stay by framing it exactly as: do you want some US troops to remain or do you want a bunch of trigger happy, unaccountable private military contractors like
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)